Now booking 2024 events. All May - October dates will book up quickly

#MenuMonday: Peanut Butter Thing

#MenuMonday: Peanut Butter Thing

This #MenuMonday we have a delicious dessert for you!  Have you ever tried the Peanut Butter Thing from Not Your Average Joe’s?  Well we found the replica recipe for it on  If you have tried it then you can continue to enjoy it for as long as you want.  If not then you should definitely try it out!  This dessert is perfect for any occasion and serves about 6-8 people.

Peanut Butter Thing
Retrieved from: Trip Advisor

Ingredients for Cookie Dough
2 1/4 oz butter
6 oz creamy peanut butter
4 oz brown sugar
4 oz flour
1/2 tbsp vanilla extract
7 oz chocolate chunks
Directions for Cookie Dough
Combine butter, peanut butter, brown sugar, flour, vanilla extract and chocolate chunks in mixing bowl with a flat utensil, like a spatula. Mix until ingredients come together like cookie dough.
Ingredients for Peanut Butter Thing Pie
1 gallon vanilla ice cream
½ qt crushed Oreo cookies
6 oz caramel sauce
½ qt crushed Oreo cookies
prepared cookie dough

Directions for Peanut Butter Thing Pie
To Assemble: Have a 10 inch round spring form cake pan ready and layer as follows.
1st Layer: Place ½ qt crushed Oreos on bottom.
2nd Layer: Ladle 2 ounces of caramel sauce over Oreos.
3rd Layer: Scoop 8 cups of cream mix over caramel sauce.
4th Layer Ladle 2 ounces of caramel sauce over ice cream mixture.
5th Layer: Evenly spread ½ qt Oreos over ice cream mixture.
6th Layer: Scoop remaining ice cream mix over Oreos.
7th Layer: Ladle 2 ounces of caramel sauce over ice cream mixture.
Top Layer: Evenly sprinkle ground Oreo crumbs over entire cake.
Wrap whole pie in plastic wrap and freeze until solid.

Original Recipe:

Make sure to let us know if you enjoyed this delicious Peanut Butter Thing!

Check back on every Monday for a #MenuMonday party food or beverage recipe! You can also subscribe to the right to have our blog articles sent directly to your inbox!

Feel free to submit your own recipes for us to share if you have a great recipe in mind for an event! We will share appetizers, meal options, desserts, and of course refreshing beverages.